Fort Plain, New York
Your local Highstreet agents in Fort Plain, providing expert advice to individuals, families, businesses and institutions in Montgomery County and throughout the Mohawk Valley and Upstate New York.

Highstreet Insurance & Financial Services Office Information
3 Canal Street
Fort Plain, NY 13339
Monday – Friday

Your local Highstreet agents in Fort Plain
Your local Highstreet agents in Fort Plain, providing insurance and financial planning for families and businesses in Montgomery County and throughout the Mohawk Valley and Upstate New York.
We’ve been in the same location in Fort Plain since 1854, with many pf the same team you’ve known for decades. Before joining Highstreet, we were Shults Insurance. Today, as Highstreet, we provide the same personal service, backed by a growing network of national specialists and a wider range of options.

Manage your account
For billing, payments, claims and policy changes, please log in to your client portal.
Local understanding. National expertise.
As part of Highstreet, we offer comprehensive personal and business insurance and more, in addition to our local expertise in Fort Plain.

Agribusiness Insurance
We understand the challenges of farming in Upstate New York, from freezing winters to summer droughts. We can help you find the right insurance to cover your home, your buildings and equipment and your crops and livestock. Let’s work together to help our rural communities thrive.

Motorsport Insurance
From ATVs to snowmobiles, we help riders in Upstate New York ride the trails with confidence. Let’s talk about protecting you, your passengers and your ride from losses due to injury, damage or theft.

Bed & Breakfasts
The Mohawk Valley has a lot to offer visitors, and smaller accommodations are one of the best ways to experience it. We work with many small family businesses like yours, providing advice and customized insurance plans to protect you and your property as well as your guests.

Employee Benefits
Businesses and organizations of every size and type, in Fort Plain, the Mohawk Valley and beyond, can hire and keep the best talent with a competitive employee benefits offering. Let’s find the right way to protect your team and keep them happy and healthy.
What people in Fort Plain say about Highstreet.
I found the office staff to be very helpful and knowledgeable. They found the best prices for my auto and homeowners insurance.
Jeffrey R.
I’m a landlord with several properties in upstate New York, and as many of you know, insurance premiums have been rising rapidly across the country. Someone referred me to Brenda…. Not only did she save me approximately $300 per policy, but she also identified several errors in the policies I had—errors that were overlooked by a very reputable company.
Sotti33
Everyone has always been helpful to me even if not doing a claim to my policy. Never have spoken to anyone who was not pleasant and knowledgeable. I have been with you all for 9-10 years and have 3 policies.
Sue P.
This is an outstanding insurance agency and the only one I deal with any longer. I grew up with the owners, and they have built an exceptional reputable business. You won’t go wrong here
I Io
Great one on one customer service. If you ask a question and they do not have an immediate answer, they always get back to you in a timely manner. Great people to do business with.
G
Frequently asked questions about our insurance coverage.
Yes, we have lots of coverage options, from property to liability, to keep your business and your guests happy campers. Learn more
New York State law requires all snowmobiles operated on public lands, trails, or roadways to carry liability insurance. If you finance or lease your ride, you may be required to carry coverage for loss or damage. Learn more
Most homeowners policies don’t cover overland flooding, such as from storms or spring melt. We can help you find options to protect your property in the Mohawk Valley and beyond. Learn more
With modern farming comes modern risks. Anything that’s connected to the internet — from grain bin monitors, pivot controls, automated feeding systems and more — can be hacked and held for ransom. We can help you protect your operation. Learn more
Marinas have lots of risks, including boaters causing accidental damage or injury at the docks. That’s why many require you to carry liability insurance to use their facilities. We can get the right coverage onboard. Learn more