Fayetteville, North Carolina
Your local Highstreet agents in Fayetteville, providing insurance for families and businesses in Cumberland County and throughout southeastern North Carolina.
Highstreet Insurance & Financial Services Office Information
2500 Raeford Road
Fayetteville, NC 28305
9am - 5pm (closed 1pm - 2pm)
Sat & Sun
Closed
Your local Highstreet agents in Fayetteville.
Your local Highstreet agents in Fayetteville, providing insurance for families and businesses in Cumberland County and throughout southeastern North Carolina.
We’ve been part of the Fayetteville community for more than 30 years, previously as Insurance of the Carolinas and the Sean S. Fincher Insurance Agency. As Highstreet, we continue to be your trusted local advocate, supported by a network of national specialists and a wider range of insurance options.
.heic?branch=production&format=auto&width=3840&quality=75)
Manage your account
For billing, claims, payments and policy changes, please log in to your client portal.
Local understanding. National expertise.
As part of Highstreet, we offer comprehensive personal and business insurance and more, in addition to our local expertise in Fayetteville.
Coastal Homes
Your oceanfront home needs special insurance coverage to manage the risks associated with coastal properties. We can show you options to get the right coverage.
Agribusiness Insurance
Whatever the size of your farming operation, we can help you cover your people, buildings, equipment, crops and livestock with the right plan. Let’s get started.
Small Business Insurance
If you’re starting a smaller local business in Fayetteville or are looking to optimize your coverage for an existing one, we can help you find the right plan for your unique needs.
Retirement Planning
Our Highstreet financial planners can help you save and invest for the retirement you want to have. We can also assist with education and estate planning.
Employee Benefits
Businesses and similar organizations of any size or kind, in North Carolina, can use a competitive benefits plan to hire and keep the best talent. Talk to one of our experts to find out how.
What people in Fayetteville say about Highstreet.
Exceptionally superior communication, follow-up and customer service from agent and staff. Convenience and timeliness in making the insurance transaction, and great rates compared to quotes received from other carriers.
Carolle Y
Their level of service is outstanding. They truly make you feel like their only client—every request or question is acknowledged promptly, usually within 24 hours, and they are always willing to take the time to explain options and answer questions thoroughly.
Shyamal S.
Excellent service from start to finish! They provided competitive pricing, great coverage options, and were extremely responsive throughout the process. Every question was answered quickly and professionally, making the entire experience easy and stress-free. I highly recommend them for anyone shopping for homeowners insurance.
Nagesh D.
Frequently asked questions about our insurance coverage.
Yes, living near a military base often affects home insurance rates in the USA, and it can lower your premiums when the base has their own dedicated emergency services. We can help you see if your specific location affects your coverage. Learn more
Your homeowners policy may cover damage from windstorms and other perils, but in Fayetteville we advise purchasing additional coverage for overland flooding and sewer backups. Let’s find the right coverage for your home and family. Learn more
PCS orders can create coverage gaps in your home and auto coverage. We can help you understand how military relocation affects any and all of your policies, so you remain fully covered. Learn more
Your homeowners policy covers your building and contents, but it has limits. If you collect jewelry, art or other valuable collectibles, it’s worth getting additional coverage for their full appraised value. Learn more